Several previous posts have discussed the odd case of Anolis lineatus on Curaçao, whose dewlap differs from one side to the other. Rand and Rand reported this in 1967, but the observation was pretty much forgotten until earlier this year, when Matt Brandley and compatriots confirmed the Rands’ claim. Shortly thereafter, Melissa Losos and I travelled to Curaçao as well and observed the same phenomenon, allaying concerns that the Brandley team was covering for the Rands.
But since these posts, many AA readers have no doubt been sleepless at night, pondering the obvious question: what about A. lineatus on Aruba? Do they, too, have mismatched throat fans? Indeed, one could imagine a scenario in which they might not. Asymmetry is a common result of low levels of genetic variation (although there is a lot of quibbling about this in the literature). Curaçao is downstream in an ocean current sense from Aruba. Thus, it could be that the Curaçao population of A. lineatus was founded by one or few Arubians, and thus the resulting founder effect gave rise to the dewlap discordance.
An exciting hypothesis that I am pleased to immediately quash:














