Species Richness Patterns in Caribbean Anolis III

Lineage accumulation curves (Fig. 2, Rabosky and Glor 2010) showing that Hispaniola (blue), Jamaica (purple), and Puerto Rico (orange) have reached speciation-extinction equilibrium. Cuba (red) is still gaining species.


Losos, J.B., and D. Schluter. 2000. Analysis of an evolutionary species-area relationship. Nature 408: 847-850.

Rabosky, D.L, and R.E. Glor. 2010. Equilibrium speciation dynamics in a model adaptive radiation of island lizards. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. 107: 22178-22183.

Losos and Schluter (2000) return to Caribbean anoles to test three hypotheses about the species-area relationship: (1) that there is an area threshold above which speciation surpasses immigration as a source of new species; (2) above the threshold size, speciation events per unit time should increase with island area; and (3) the slope of the species-area relationship should become steeper above the area threshold. Qualitatively similar to Losos (1996), this paper was novel in that a newly available, nearly complete, mt-DNA phylogeny allowed Losos and Schluter to reconstruct immigration and speciation events and to model whether species number has reached speciation-extinction equilibrium.

Anolis cristatellus, and Life’s Unexpected Twists and Turns

Read all about it here.

Vacation in Vieques, Complete with Anoles

Frigid temperatures in Boston are making me long for the warm waters of Vieques, PR and the time I was there in October.  Truth be told, I work for Jonathan Losos in a mostly administrative role, but even that has turned me into an avid lizard hunter when on vacation in the tropics.  I even set a goal for myself – to find and photograph all three species of anoles on the island – except for the one no one has seen in almost 100 years.  I trusted that if several professionals have not been able to find A. roosevelti, than my chances were slim (although, I did keep my eyes out for large lizards falling out of trees, just in case).  To my absolute delight, the other three species,  A. cristatellus, A. pulchellus, and A. stratulus could all be seen running around the manicured garden that surrounded the house I was staying in.   We named one “King” and watched him move from palm tree to palm tree, displaying to the other anoles in the vicinity.  (I’ve observed many anoles in Ecuador, but had never seen an anole move its tail back and forth before as a display – adorable!)

I watched a spirited courtship between a male and female A. pulchellus in ferns, and spent far too much time trying to get a shot of A. stratulus – particularly one that could always be seen on the wall of the pool house, but would promptly run through the door when I pulled out my camera.

There was even an A. stratulus running around without a front hand.  He seemed to move about just fine, though, both through the house and around the vegetation outside.  I was proud of my non-biologist friend that worried about him missing “so many sticky toes”.    Also entertaining was a fight between two juveniles – unfortunately shot with my cheap telephoto lens, so the quality is poor, but it’s still entertaining: video

Looking forward to a week in the Bahamas in May – another vacation, but I’m sure it too will be filled with anoles.

Species Richness Patterns in Caribbean Anolis II

Losos, J.B. 1996. Ecological and evolutionary determinants of the species-area relation in Caribbean anoline lizards. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B 351: 847-854.

As alluded to previously,  MacArthur and Wilson (1967) did consider evolutionary processes when they developed their Theory of Island Biogeography. Specifically, in situ evolutionary diversification (i.e. speciation) may contribute substantially to the species diversity of an island and should be considered in any general attempt to model species-area relationships on islands. Building on Rand’s 1969 paper studying the ecological determinants of species richness in Caribbean anoles, Losos (1996) incorporates an evolutionary perspective into the Caribbean Anolis species-area story.

Updates from SICB: Dewlap Recap

Hello again from North Charleston!

We started off strong: this morning’s “Sexual Selection in Herps” session was dominated by anole talks. Bieke Vanhooydonck, from the University of Antwerp, discussed sexual dimorphism and dewlap growth in Anolis baracoae. By repeatedly measuring individuals over the course of their development into adulthood, Vanhooydonck observed a number of morphological changes. All the observed morphological characteristics showed no significant difference between males and females, with only the key exception of dewlap size. Male dewlaps were found to be larger. The development of dewlaps in the genders diverges, and the male dewlaps subsequently outgrow the female dewlaps, when lizards reach sexual maturity. An interesting and unexpected discovery made by this study was the significant decrease in male dewlap size that occurs with old age. Vanhooydonck proposed that this might be caused by loss of elasticity in skin.

Following her was Michele Johnson of Trinity University, who discussed the interplay of natural and sexual selection in Anolis sagrei and Anolis maynardi. She hypothesized that the difference in head shapes for male and female Anolis lizards may be driven by diet, male-male competition, or female choice. Looking to the particularly elongated head of A. maynardi, Michele explored the potential function implications of extreme head shape. Actively foraging A. maynardi lizards appeared to move more than “sit-and-wait strategists” A. sagrei. In A. maynardi dominance trials, Michele found that the winner of male-male territorial competitions is most commonly the male with the shorter snout (and therefore increased bite force). However, in female choice trials it was observed that females most frequently chose the male with the longer snout. Although she noted her findings are still preliminary, this leaves us with an intriguing question: if the selective forces from male competition and female choice are counteracting one another, what will ultimately determine snout length in A. maynardi populations?

A bit later, Martha Muñoz (ñote: with regard to the ñame-tag failure, it is really ñot that hard to type ñ. C’mon SICB) presented her research on behavioral and physiological adaptations to the thermal environment in the Hispaniolan cybotes group.  The diverse species of lizard in this group occupy a broad range of elevation, habitat composition, and thermal environment. If Anolis lizards are not using behavior to mitigate extreme temperatures in their habitat, we might anticipate changes in physiology. No differences were observed between the study species preferred or mean field body temperatures, which implies that they are actively and purposefully thermoregulating. However, she explained that there are limits to behavioral control. What if there was no access to shade for reprieve from the heat? Or what if it was too cold to bask? From her data, Martha suggests that the cybotoids are able to evade extreme heat, but an inability to avoid extreme cold in some environments has made it advantageous to adapt a physiological tolerance to the cold.

The poster session was dotted with Anolis research as well, including such topics as A. carolinensis satellite cells and tissue regeneration. Ellie Cook, who I met while she was working with Michele Johnson in the Dominican Republic this summer, had a great poster displaying her analysis of the affect of parasitism on dewlap coloration in Anolis brevirostris. Her data show that whiter, duller dewlaps are correlated with greater ectoparasite loads. She suggests this may the result of cartenoids being diverted during parasite-instigated immune response.

This has been a fantastic first conference experience for me! I am really sorry to be leaving so soon. I have been super impressed by the Anole community’s contributions to SICB – please keep updating, guys!

Actual Anoles at SICB 2012

There’s more than just anole biologists congregating at the SICB 2012 meeting.

To say it’s been cold here in Charleston, SC would be an understatement. Tuesday night, after the conference tipped off, it was 25 degrees Fahrenheit. But today, the temperature picked up a bit and moved into the 50s. Since we know they don’t hibernate in the winter months, I thought it might be possible that the local anoles may take advantage of the sunny afternoon to do a little basking. Just as the poster session was underway at about 3pm, I decided to give it a shot and take a look around what would be prime Anolis carolinensis habitat in the spring and summer: the bushes and a brick wall around the pool.

Sure enough, I spotted one male and two females right away! I texted Bryan Falk immediately, and we set to flexing our off-season collecting muscles. Doing a quick tour around the conference center, we managed to observe 6 and catch 3. No anoles were injured during this brief collecting trip – perhaps only mildly perturbed 🙂

We spotted a female on a sun-drenched black lamp post. Nice warm spot on an otherwise cool day.

Here's a sweet lady I snatched from a vine-laden verandah at the back of the conference center.

Bryan Falk with female green anole. Note the winter plumage on the human.

 

Anoles Are Off To A Great Start At SICB!

Greetings, Anole Annals readers, from lovely Charleston. It may not be balmy here, but it’s warmer than my usual habitat of Cambridge, Massachusetts, which is currently experiencing an “Arctic front,” which is fancy speak for blistering cold wind. For those of you who couldn’t be here, this morning held some great Anolis talks at SICB, and I was able to attend three. The first was by Maureen Stimola, a senior undergraduate student at Columbia University who did her senior thesis with me in the Dominican Republic this past summer. Maureen’s research project addressed how thermal tolerance (CTmin and CTmax) changes with elevation in the cybotoids (A. cybotes and related trunk-grounds) from the Dominican Republic.

Asymmetrical dewlap color in Anolis lineatus on Curaçao

In September, 2011, Alex Dornburg (Yale), Andy Jones (Yale), Teresa Iglesias (UC Davis), Dan Warren (UT Austin) and I made our yearly pilgrimage to study the marine and herpetological fauna of Curaçao. On the advice of J. Losos, one of our missions this year was to document the dewlap color asymmetry in Anolis lineatus.

In 1967, Stan and Patricia Rand published a paper on the natural history of A. lineatus and noted that:

“The dewlap is large in the male; extended it has a wide border with bright orange skin around a block central spot. The spot is crossed by several widely separated rows of white scales. The border on one side is closely set with yellow or whitish scales, on the other side, the scales are rudimentary and colored like the skin. About half the males have the scales well developed on the right side of the dewlap, about half on the left… one side of the dewlap appears to have a bright orange border, the other side a yellow orange border. The females have a much smaller dewlap, but colored like the males’ and also asymmetrical, though less conspicuously so.”

We braved multiple attacks of push-ups and head bobs and managed to collect and photograph multiple individuals.

Note the large, white scales in the orange field of the dewlaps:

versus the other side of the dewlap which lacks the large, white scales:

The orange vs. yellow-orange difference is a bit subtle and not easily visible in these photos, but it’s there.  Like Rand and Rand, we found a roughly equal distribution of individuals with the white scales on the left, and those on the right.

What explains this asymmetry?   Are they using the different colors to warn males and attract females?

We are thinking of hypotheses to test during our 2012 trip to the island and we’d appreciate hearing other ideas from other researchers.

Illustrations by A. Seago

 

Posthumous Co-Authorship: What Are the Rules?

In a recent AA exchange, it was noted that Ernest Williams’ last publication appeared 11 years after his death. Anthony Geneva wondered “how far one could take posthumous co-authorship. What’s stopping me from including Darwin as a co-author on my next manuscript?”

Indeed, just what are the rules? Are you comfortable with the idea that a paper may be published in the future and the deceased you listed as a co-author, without the opportunity to agree to be a coauthor, much less comment on or contribute to its content? What’s to keep someone just from tacking on the names of prominent figures in a bid to make a paper more publishable or to gain more attention?

In this case, the paper, Poe et al. (2009), made clear their rationale:

Species Richness Patterns in Caribbean Anolis I

This is the first of a series of posts that will review a number of papers that examined species richness patterns in anoles, starting with Rand’s 1969 paper described below and moving towards the present day understanding. Read on!

Species richness predictions from the Theory of Island Biogeography

 Rand, A.S. 1969. Competitive exclusion among anoles (Sauria: Iguanidae) on small islands in the West Indies. Breviora 319: 1-16.

The empirically observed species-area relationship (SAR) is one of the closest things to a law that we have in evolutionary ecology. All else equal, the larger the area, the more species will be in it. In a paper in 1963, and a book in 1967, MacArthur and Wilson (M&W) put forward the Theory of Island Biogeography (TIB) to explain the species-area relationship on islands. They observed that the number of species that inhabit an island scales positively with island area and negatively with distance of an island from the mainland species source. M&W argued that the SAR is governed by two ecological processes: colonization and extinction. Colonization probability increases with the size of an island and decreases with island distance from the mainland. Extinction probability increases as island size decreases because small islands support smaller population sizes and leave species are more vulnerable to fluctuations in abiotic and biotic environmental factors. Thus, the TIB predicts that large islands close to the mainland will be species rich, while small islands far from the mainland will be species poor. The TIB inspired thousands of papers: according to Google Scholar, the 1967 book has been cited 11,148 times and the 1963 paper has been cited 1,416 times.

Page 254 of 300

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén