Paper accepted, proofs corrected.
Next, the movie adaptation. But who will play Green Anole?
Author: Jonathan Losos Page 116 of 131
Professor of Biology and Director of the Living Earth Collaborative at Washington University in Saint Louis. I've spent my entire professional career studying anoles and have discovered that the more I learn about anoles, the more I realize I don't know.
Barely even kissing cousins: A. aequatorialis on the left and A. fitchi (photo thanks to Chris Funk) on the right.
The new Castañeda and de Queiroz phylogeny of Dactyloa is an important advance in our understanding of anole phylogenetics. Prior to this paper, relationships among clades within Dactyloa had been little studied; indeed, the monophyly of Dactyloa was in question, with a viable alternative being that Dactyloa is a paraphyletic group from which the rest of Anolis sprang. Not only have Castañeda and de Queiroz convincingly laid this possibility to rest, but they have identified five strongly supported clades. As the previous AA post on this paper noted, these clades are geographically coherent, revealing five geographically distinct theaters of Dactyloa diversification.
The paper has important implications in several other respects:
1. Size evolution: Dactyloa is known for its giant anoles (officially defined by Lazell as an anole exceeding 100 mm in snout-vent length). Almost all giant Dactyloa belong to the latifrons clade, all members of which, save one, are giants.
2. Convergence: In a number of cases, species that were thought to be closely-related were found to occur in different clades. The most amazing of these are A. aequatorialis and A. fitchi (pictured above), so similar in appearance and ecology that they were thought to be sister taxa that replaced each other on opposite sides of the Andes. However, it turns out that they are not at all closely related and belong in different clades.
3. Evolutionary divergence: an underexplored aspect is the extent of evolutionary diversification within clades of Dactyloa. Though much remains to be learned, it is clear that diversification has been quite extensive, as a number of the clades contain an ecomorphological array of species. The Western clade, for example, contains species such as festae, peraccae, chloris, aequatorialis, and gemmosus, which are very distinct from each other morphologically and utilize different parts of the structural habitat. Collecting the necessary morphological, ecological and behavioral data to trace the pattern of Dactyloa radiation will be an exciting challenge in the coming years!
In sum, this paper importantly advances our understanding of anole evolution. If now we could only crack that Norops nut!
Unidentified anole by Miguel Landestoy from the Philadelphia Inquirer. Who can name that species (not Miguel!)?
Faye Flam’s Planet of the Apes column in today’s Philadelphia Inquirer is entitled “Is Life Inevitably or Chance? Lizards May Tell.” Turns out that anoles may hold the answer to some of life’s most profound questions.
Phenacosaurus orcesi. Photo by Melissa Woolley.
As I prepared for our current trip to Ecuador to study the natural history of Phenacosaurus orcesi, I feared that we would not find any lizards. After all, until recently, the species was known from only two specimens. What if we simply couldn’t find them?
These fears were assuaged when I reviewed the literature—scant as it is—on phenacosaur ecology. In the most comprehensive study, Miyata found 77 P. heterodermus individuals in blackberry bushes in five afternoons of observations at a site near Bogota. On seeing the previous AA post, Vic Hutchison also recalled finding P. heterodermus in blackberry bushes in Colombia. George Gorman mentioned to me that he collected phenacs in a suburb of Bogota in the summer on 1968, and he recalls that “it was a like Lesser Antillean experience…rather than a ‘mainland’ experience, in that the lizards were abundant, easily collected, and on fenceposts and hedges.” In addition, the original description of P. vanzolinii states that “the local people say that the ‘camaleon o camaleon’ is common in the fields of maize.”
From all of this information, I formed the hypothesis that finding phenacs would be easy, that we’d be awash with data and would finish so early that we could go traipsing off elsewhere in Ecuador. In other words, I set myself up for the Principle of Unsympathetic Magic to rear its ugly head, and it did so with a vengeance.
Brown phase green anole. Photo by Janson Jones at Dust Tracks on the Web (http://dusttracks.com/)
At Dust Tracks on the Web, Janson Jones posts some interesting observations on green anoles (A. carolinensis) in northern Florida and southern Georgia, where the brown anole (A. sagrei) has yet to invade. To cut to the chase, he finds the green anoles to be larger, to be brown more often, and to perch much lower than green anoles do in central Florida in the presence of brown anoles.
The effect of brown anoles on greens in Florida has been surprisingly poorly documented. Just as surprisingly, very little information exists in the scientific literature on the habitat use, behavior, and other aspects of green anole natural history in places where they occur by themselves. We have almost no useful data on what green anole biology was like in Florida pre-sagrei, nor few data from areas where sagrei does not occur today. Detailed and quantitative studies of such populations would be particularly useful, as well as repeated surveys through time in areas that brown anoles may eventually invade to document what happens when they get there (of course, repeated surveys in areas that brown anoles don’t invade would be important to, as controls). Those of you who live in appropriate areas, get to it!
Who knows what Phenacosaurus dreams about?
On her very first day of anole fieldwork, soon-to-be graduate student Katie B. experienced a clear example of the wisdom of Ernest Williams. Out at night looking for anoles with her soon-to-be advisor, they came across the first Phenacosaurus orcesi of the trip, clinging to a narrow, vertical twig about eight feet above the ground. This led to a long pontification by the advisor on how some anoles sleep on leaves, others on branches, and so on, but how P. orcesi, in so many respects similar to twig anoles, would surely only be found sleeping on the twigs to which it is so well adapted, and would abjure all vegetated slumber sites. Needless to say, the next phenacosaur found that evening was snoozing sprawled across a leaf (as well as the next one found the following evening), teaching Katie both about the Principle of Unsympathetic Magic and the general lack of veracity of anything her advisor-to-be says.
p.s. Katie won the candy bar for correctly predicting the number of lizards captured on the first evening.
Phenacosaurus heterodermus (photo from http://www.flickr.com/photos/sngcanary/4207771662/)
“Among the strange and varied production of the high Andes is a small assemblage of grotesque, big-headed, short-legged, prehensile-tailed lizards: the genus Phenacosaurus.”
So starts Skip Lazell’s (1969) taxonomic revision of the three species in the anoline genus Phenacosaurus. Since that time, there have really been only two developments in phenac world. First, phylogenetic studies have conclusively demonstrated that phenacosaurs represent an evolutionary offshoot within the Dactyloa clade of anoles. As a result, most systematists now consider these species to be members of the genus Anolis, though some diehard romantics/heretics still use Phenacosaurus. Second, the last 40 years have seen a veritable phenaco-population explosion, with 11 species now recognized, and word on the street that more are on the way.
Despite these advances, our knowledge of phenacosaur biology has barely budged since Lazell’s time.
Those rascals! I’ve heard reports of this before, but never seen a photo. I wonder if it’s always a male green anole, or whether both ways occur. In any case, it would be shocking if such liaisons led to the production of hybrid offspring, given that the two species belong to evolutionary lineages that separated many many millions of years ago.
Another spectacular anole photo from Eladio Fernández, the author of the wonderful book on Hispaniolan biodiversity, Hispaniola: A Photographic Journey Through Island Biodiversity. See some of Eladio’s photos–and others–here. But you need to go to his book for the stunning shots of a solenodon in the wild. Anolis insolitus, incidentally, is a twig anole from Hispaniola. This photo was taken at the Ebano Verde Scientific Reserve.
This letter was just received from Dr. Jennifer Rahn (jlrahn@gmail.com):
Hi Anole friends,
We think we have some strange anole behavior on Saba (Dutch Caribbean) this week. No one has seen the indigenous Saba Anole (Anolis sabanus) with this blue belly before. Have any of you heard of it in other species? We think it may be a stray species from a nearby island, unless of course it is some alpha male or other strange but infrequent anolis behavior.
Please let us know if you can explain this to us.
Curious Sabans
Any thoughts? It’s definitely A. sabanus (sometimes called the “panther anole” in the pet trade, and one of my favorite species).